Skip to content

The Bumps Ahead: Challenges in Governing Rapidly-Evolving AI Systems

Artificial intelligence (AI) has huge potential to transform our world and provide major societal benefits, but it also comes with risks if not governed properly. As AI systems become more powerful and widespread, there is growing recognition that we need governance frameworks to ensure these technologies are developed safely, ethically, and aligned with human values. But what exactly should we expect from AI governance?

Definition and Goals
AI governance refers to the laws, policies, standards, and institutions created specifically to oversee the development and deployment of AI. The overarching goal is to maximize the benefits of AI while minimizing the harms. This includes objectives like supporting innovation in the field, managing risks from advanced AI systems, ensuring justice and fairness, building public trust, and coordinating between different groups working in AI.

Key Focus Areas
There are a few key domains that effective AI governance will likely focus on:

Research and Innovation – Supporting cutting-edge research and commercial innovation with AI through funding, infrastructure, and appropriate regulations. However, some restrictions may be imposed on areas like autonomous weapons or invasive surveillance.

Ethics and Alignment – Ensuring AI systems respect ethical principles and norms around issues like transparency, accountability, bias mitigation, and human control of autonomous systems. Mechanisms will be needed to translate ethical guidelines into action.

Safety and Control – Developing techniques to ensure advanced AI systems behave as intended over the long-term and monitoring systems for signs of unintended behavior. Governance will be challenged to enable innovation while restricting uncontrolled propagation of advanced AI.

Economic Impacts – Monitoring and managing the broad economic impacts of AI automation and AI-enhanced decision making across industries and labor markets. Targeted programs may help workers transition to new jobs.

International Cooperation – Promoting collaboration and unified principles on AI governance globally while respecting national sovereignty. This coordination will be crucial as impacts spread worldwide.

Institutions and Approaches
We can expect a multilayered fabric of institutions and approaches to oversee responsible AI development, similar to other major technologies like biotech or nuclear power.

At the broadest level, intergovernmental organizations like the UN or OECD may set international norms and policy recommendations on AI. However, they have limited ability to enforce rules.

Individual national governments will likely create legislative and regulatory frameworks on AI safety, ethics, and competitiveness. We may see dedicated AI oversight agencies similar to those for data privacy.

Within the private sector, many companies are establishing voluntary principles and standards around issues like algorithmic bias, data practices, and AI safety research. Governments may reference or incorporate these.

Technical standards bodies will also set benchmarks around topics like model transparency, testing procedures, and methods to verify claims from AI providers.

Independent watchdog groups and consumer organizations will pressure both the public and private sectors for responsible AI policies.

Academic communities in areas like computer science, law, philosophy, and economics will significantly influence AI governance through research and expert recommendations.

Multistakeholder initiatives that convene companies, civil society groups, academics, and public sector experts will grow in prominence for negotiating collective norms and practices.

The Path Forward
In the years ahead, we can expect to see considerable experimentation, debate, and refinement around AI governance. There remains much diversity of opinion on optimal approaches. It will be a continual challenge to strike the right balance between supporting innovation, managing risks appropriately, building public trust, and not over-regulating the field. Strong evidence-based policymaking will be critical. It is unlikely consensus will emerge quickly, but the conversations are undoubtedly moving forward. AI governance promises to be one of the defining policy issues of the 21st century.